TAP A332 at Lisbon on Jul 12th 2014, engine shut down in flight
Last Update: June 15, 2016 / 18:38:38 GMT/Zulu time
Incident Facts
Date of incident
Jul 12, 2014
Classification
Incident
Airline
TAP Air Portugal
Flight number
TP-85
Departure
Lisbon, Portugal
Destination
Sao Paulo Guarulhos, Brazil
Aircraft Registration
CS-TOO
Aircraft Type
Airbus A330-200
ICAO Type Designator
A332
Lisbon police reported debris off the aircraft damaged a number of vehicles in Camarate just north of the runway end.
The airline confirmed an engine malfunction, however said it was not an engine explosion.
A replacement Airbus A330-200 registration CS-TOH departed Lisbon with a delay of about 12.5 hours and is estimated to reach Sao Paulo with a delay of 12:20 hours.
The airline's chairman reported on Jul 16th that a high pressure turbine's vane, located just at the exit of the combustion chamber and thus taking the highest temperatures, came loose, a problem that was introduced during manufacturing of the engine.
On Jun 15th 2016 Portugal's GPIAA released their final report concluding the probable cause of the incident was:
Low temperature hot corrosion (Hot Corrosion Type II) assisted cracking below the fixing platform of High Pressure Turbine stage one blades causing blade separation during the initial climb phase.
Contributing factors were:
- The difficulty for the engine manufacturer, for reasons related to the contracts with the various operators and/or availability, to schedule an earlier Quick Turn that resulted in ESN 811471 engine reaching a CSN above the desired (taking into account the record of previous events) for its removal;
- The engines’ exposure to corrosive elements such as dust, sand, pollution and salt (operation over and close to maritime environment) due to the intrinsic type of operation;
- The engines’ exposure to hot and dry environment due to the intrinsic type of operation;
- The high content of sulfur in aviation fuel at international level.
The GPIAA reported that the first officer (30, ATPL, 4,734 hours total, 112 hours on type) was pilot flying, immediately upon the engine failure the captain (61, ATPL, 8,202 hours total, 3,237 hours on type) took control of the aircraft.
The crew commenced a flex takeoff departure from Lisbon's runway 03 assuming an outside temperature of +39 degrees C and was climbing through 1300 feet AGL, the gear had just retracted, when a loud noise was heard in the cockpit and engine instruments showed an EGT of 1060 degrees C and N1 vibrations of 7.7 units for the right hand engine. The captain, taking control of the aircraft, immediately reduced the right hand thrust to idle and declared emergency advising he wanted to climb straight out to 3000 feet. The crew subsequently worked the related checklists identifying the engine parameters were consistent with damage, in order to secure the engine the crew discharged one fire bottle.
ATC requested the aircraft to climb to 5000 feet for a fuel dump, which the crew complied with. The aircraft dumped about 40 tons of fuel in 41 minutes. The aircraft subsequently positioned for an ILS approach to runway 03, descending through 1000 feet AGL the crew received indication of a nose wheel steering fault and advised ATC they might not be able to vacate the runway. The aircraft landed safely, the crew managed to vacate the runway and stopped on taxiway U4, the aircraft was subsequently towed to the apron.
The GPIAA wrote: "As a result of the contained engine failure, there was some damage to some windows of cars and of a house as the A330 was overflying the town of Camarate (Santiago neighbourhood)."
The GPIAA analysed:
Around the world, from June 2006 until July 2014, there were 13 GE’s CF6-80E1A engines High Pressure Turbine blade liberation events on A330-200/300 aircraft series.
In 9 events, which include the TAP085 one, the engines were equipped with blades P11 and in the remaining 4 were P17 blades.
Out of these 13 events, 11 occurred under the fixing platform at the High Pressure Turbine due to a Hot Corrosion Type II attack.
Most of these events took place whilst the aircraft were in flight (7 IFSD).
Present available techniques unable assessment of under the platform HPT stage one blade condition regarding hot corrosion attacks unless the blades are individually dismantled from the turbine and analysed.
Assessment of under the fixing platform blade condition is performed when the HPT stage one blades are removed at Shop Visit and/or by visual inspection of the blades before Shop Visit (as per SEB 72-0468 - implemented in May 2012), therefore engine manufacturers have a difficult task in scheduling recommended Shop Visits for the turbine stage one blades removal.
One of the most important parameters used to assess engine potential is the number of cycles performed. Consequently, the flight hours to flight cycle ratio is also of vital importance in the “attempt” to determine engine wear.
TAP and GE have been working together on understanding and reducing TAP’s fleet exposure to HPT stage one blade liberation events.
The assessment of the blades is continuous, as the engines go to Shop Visit, with the purpose of gaining further understanding of the hardware condition and, if deemed necessary, re-evaluate the threshold.
The flight hour to flight cycle ratio at TAP is 8.2, considered by GE to be above the area of concern when comparing TAP to the CF6-80E1 fleet as most of these events occurred on engines flying between 3 to 5 flight hours to cycle ratio.
Stage one HPT blade separation event of TAP085 was due to corrosion assisted cracking below the fixing platform, which is similar to other events occurred with CF6-80E1 engines.
At the time of the event, ESN 811471 had 4070 CSN (and 33340 hours TSN).
Incident Facts
Date of incident
Jul 12, 2014
Classification
Incident
Airline
TAP Air Portugal
Flight number
TP-85
Departure
Lisbon, Portugal
Destination
Sao Paulo Guarulhos, Brazil
Aircraft Registration
CS-TOO
Aircraft Type
Airbus A330-200
ICAO Type Designator
A332
This article is published under license from Avherald.com. © of text by Avherald.com.
Article source
You can read 2 more free articles without a subscription.
Subscribe now and continue reading without any limits!
Read unlimited articles and receive our daily update briefing. Gain better insights into what is happening in commercial aviation safety.
Send tip
Support AeroInside by sending a small tip amount.
Related articles
TAP A332 at New York on May 26th 2023, hit something on departure
A TAP Air Portugal Airbus A330-200, registration CS-TOO performing flight TP-208 from New York JFK,NY (USA) to Lisbon (Portugal) with 267 people on…
TAP A320 at Copenhagen on Apr 8th 2022, reverser opened on TOGA, overflew buildings at very low height on go around
A TAP Air Portugal Airbus A320-200, registration CS-TNV performing flight TP-754 from Lisbon (Portugal) to Copenhagen (Denmark) with 102 passengers…
TAP A20N at Conakry on Sep 2nd 2022, hits motorbike on landing
A TAP Air Portugal Airbus A320-200N, registration CS-TVI performing flight TP-1492 from Lisbon (Portugal) to Conakry (Guinea) with 73 passengers and…
TAP A21N near Barcelona on Oct 23rd 2023, engine failure
A TAP Air Portugal Airbus A321-200N, registration CS-TJL performing flight TP-823 from Milan Malpensa (Italy) to Lisbon (Portugal), was enroute at…
TAP A21N at Madrid on Sep 3rd 2023, descent below minimum safe altitude on approach, EGPWS saves the day
A TAP Air Portugal Airbus A321-200N, registration CS-TXD performing flight TP-1024 from Lisbon (Portugal) to Madrid,SP (Spain) with 136 passengers…
TAP A339 over Atlantic on Sep 12th 2023, cracked windshield
A TAP Air Portugal Airbus A330-900, registration CS-TUA performing flight TP-207 from Lisbon (Portugal) to Newark,NJ (USA), was enroute at FL390 over…
Newest articles
Envoy E175 at Washington on May 1st 2024, bird strike causes flap fail
An Envoy Embraer ERJ-175 on behalf of American Airlines, registration N205NN performing flight AA-4168 from Washington National,DC to Key West,FL…
PAL DH8D at St. John's on May 1st 2024, overran runway on landing
A PAL Provincial Airlines de Havilland Dash 8-400, registration C-GPNE performing flight PB-3072 from Halifax,NS to St. John's,NL (Canada), had…
Subscribe today
Are you researching aviation incidents? Get access to AeroInside Insights, unlimited read access and receive the daily newsletter.
Pick your plan and subscribePartner
A new way to document and demonstrate airworthiness compliance and aircraft value. Find out more.
ELITE Simulation Solutions is a leading global provider of Flight Simulation Training Devices, IFR training software as well as flight controls and related services. Find out more.
Your regulation partner, specialists in aviation safety and compliance; providing training, auditing, and consultancy services. Find out more.
AeroInside Blog
Popular aircraft
Airbus A320Boeing 737-800
Boeing 737-800 MAX
Popular airlines
American AirlinesUnited
Delta
Air Canada
Lufthansa
British Airways