Jet2 B738 at Reus on May 12th 2019, TCAS RA during missed approach
Last Update: March 18, 2020 / 20:35:31 GMT/Zulu time
Spain's CIAIAC reported a private aircraft, a Diamond DA20, had entered the control zone of Reuss and had been instructed to maintain 3500 feet or above due to an exhibition of aerobatic flights in the Tarragona (Reus) area. The trajectories of the DA20 and the B738 converged, the crew of the Boeing received a TCAS RA and complied performing the evasive maneouver. The separation between the two aircraft reduced to 100 feet vertical and 0.9nm horizontal. The occurrence is being investigated by the CIAIAC.
On Mar 18th 2020 the CIAIAC released their final report concluding the probable cause of the serious incident was:
The investigation has determined that this incident occurred because the controller under instruction and the instructor controller lost situational awareness of the traffic under their control.
The following factors contributed to the incident:
- Providing an inadequate clearance to the visual traffic EC-KMH, in terms of the altitude to maintain, as the lower clearance limit (3500 ft) conflicted with the ILS approach maneuver cleared to aircraft G-GDFS
- Not using the surveillance radar.
- The placement of the strips in the holder, as well as the use of various fixes (runway, pattern, approach), differed from those normally used by the instructor controller.
- AESA’s assignment, in coordination with ENAIRE, of an area very close to the Reus Airport for exhibition flights.
The CIAIAC summarized the sequence of events:
On Sunday, 12 May 2019, a Boeing 737-86N aircraft, registration G-GDFS, inbound from Manchester, was on approach to the Reus Airport. It had missed its previous landing maneuver and, at the time of the incident, it was on the outbound leg at 3800 ft in preparation to make a new ILS Y approach to runway 25. (The instrument approach chart published in the AIP states that the outbound leg should be flown descending from an altitude of 5000 ft to 3800 ft at DME mile 13 on the ILS. On the outbound leg, DME mile 13 on the ILS practically coincides with reporting point E).
The Diamond DA20-C1, registration EC-KMH, was preparing to enter the Reus Airport CTR via reporting point E. The visual approach chart published in the AIP states that arrivals via point E of the CTR must be made at a maximum altitude of 2000 ft; however, this aircraft had been instructed by the controller to maintain 3,500 ft or higher due to an aerobatic air show over Tarragona. At the time of the incident, the aircraft was flying at 3,800 ft.
The controller in the Reus control tower was receiving on-the-job instruction and was being supervised by the instructor controller. The instructor controller decided to set up the control tower radar to show only the Reus ATZ airspace since the Unit Training Plan states that the approach control service provided is procedural.
Neither the controller under instruction nor the instructor was aware of the potential conflict. The flight paths of both aircraft converged and G-GDFS received a TCAS RA, as a result of which it executed an avoidance maneuver that cleared the conflict.
The minimum horizontal distance between the two aircraft was 0.6 NM, and the vertical distance 200 ft.
There were no injuries and the aircraft were not damaged.
The CIAIAC analysed the controllers' actions:
The conflict was not identified by the controller under instruction or by the instructor controller, neither of whom reacted to it. In fact, before the conflict, no traffic information was provided to either of the two aircraft involved in this incident.
When the aircraft with callsign EXS929 informed him that there was an aircraft 200 ft below, the controller replied to stand by. In other words, the controller lacked the situational awareness needed to give the traffic an effective response.
Sixteen seconds later, when the crew of EXS929 told him they had started an avoidance maneuver, the controller instructed the other aircraft to descend to an altitude of 2000 ft, infringing the area reserved for the acrobatic air show that reached up to 3,300 feet, and informed EXS929 of the instruction given to the latter.
Although this instruction by the controller did not conflict with the TCAS resolution advisories, he did not follow the procedure established by ENAIRE for these situations, which calls for radio silence from ATC until the TCAS itself clears the conflict. Therefore, given the gravity of this event, it is recommended that ENAIRE provide refresher training to controllers at the unit on the procedure to follow in the event of a TCAS RA.
This article is published under license from Avherald.com. © of text by Avherald.com.
Read unlimited articles and receive our daily update briefing. Gain better insights into what is happening in commercial aviation safety.
Support AeroInside by sending a small tip amount.
A Jet2.com Boeing 737-800, registration G-GDFP performing flight LS-1711 from Manchester,EN (UK) to Dalaman (Turkey) with 161 passengers and 6 crew,…
A Jet2.com Boeing 737-300, registration G-GDFM performing flight LS-255 from Leeds,EN (UK) to Girona,SP (Spain), was climbing out of Leeds' runway 32…
A Jet2.com Boeing 737-800, registration G-DRTW performing flight LS-189 from Glasgow,SC (UK) to Palma Mallorca,SP (Spain) with 187 passengers and 6…
A Jet2.com Airbus A321-200N, registration G-SUNB performing flight LS-984 from Bodrum (Turkey) to Manchester,EN (UK), was climbing out of Bodrum's…
A Jet2.com Boeing 757-200, registration G-LSAI performing flight LS-781 from Manchester,EN (UK) to Las Palmas,CI (Spain), was climbing out of…
A Virgin Australia Boeing 737-800, registration VH-YQR performing flight VA-916 from Brisbane,QL to Sydney,NS (Australia) with 179 passengers and 6…
An S7 Sibir Airlines Boeing 737-800, legal registration VQ-BKV (illegal disowned registration RA-73665) performing flight S7-2502 from Novosibirsk to…
Are you researching aviation incidents? Get access to AeroInside Insights, unlimited read access and receive the daily newsletter.Pick your plan and subscribe
A new way to document and demonstrate airworthiness compliance and aircraft value. Find out more.
ELITE Simulation Solutions is a leading global provider of Flight Simulation Training Devices, IFR training software as well as flight controls and related services. Find out more.
Your regulation partner, specialists in aviation safety and compliance; providing training, auditing, and consultancy services. Find out more.
Popular aircraftAirbus A320
Boeing 737-800 MAX
Popular airlinesAmerican Airlines